Judge dismisses Patriot Water lawsuit against ODNR - WFMJ.com News weather sports for Youngstown-Warren Ohio

Judge dismisses Patriot Water lawsuit against ODNR

Posted: Updated:

WARREN, Ohio - A judge has dismissed A Warren water treatment plant's lawsuit against the Ohio Department of Natural Resources of intentionally hiding and/or destroying evidence while legal cases were pending related to their EPA permit.

Patriot Water Treatment claims ODNR interfered with or destroyed evidence and disposed specific public records requested between 2009 and 2011.

Patriot claims this hurt their litigation options when the EPA said the city of Warren could no longer accept Patriot's water and forced them out of business for three months.

However, Judge Patrick McGrath ruled that the Court of Claims in Columbus lacked jurisdiction over the public records claim and lawsuit. He also said that the plant should have filed the suit earlier with the Ohio Environment Protection Agency.

In July, the Ohio Environmental Review Appeals Commission ruled the EPA's decision was unlawful.

The company is asking for $3,500,000 in monetary damages and injunctive relief.

  • More NewsMore>>

  • Youngstown Police investigate burglary at Cornersburg coffee shop

    Youngstown Police investigate burglary at Cornersburg coffee shop

    Saturday, August 19 2017 6:07 PM EDT2017-08-19 22:07:55 GMT

    Youngstown Police are reviewing surveillance video after someone broke into a Cornersburg coffee drive-thru early Saturday. Officers rushed to Stone Fruit Espresso to Go around 2:30 a.m. after an alarm went off.  According to officials, the drive-thru window was smashed and blood droplets were on the window frame and on the floor inside the business.  

    More >>

    Youngstown Police are reviewing surveillance video after someone broke into a Cornersburg coffee drive-thru early Saturday. Officers rushed to Stone Fruit Espresso to Go around 2:30 a.m. after an alarm went off.  According to officials, the drive-thru window was smashed and blood droplets were on the window frame and on the floor inside the business.  

    More >>
  • New Castle man convicted of child sex trafficking

    New Castle man convicted of child sex trafficking

    Saturday, August 19 2017 2:46 PM EDT2017-08-19 18:46:42 GMT

     A New Castle man could be sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty in federal court to a charge of sex trafficking of a child. Ronald Kyle Hartman, 28, entered the plea on Monday in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh. Hartman, along with 24-year-old David Monrean, also of New Castle, were indicted in January following an investigation by the FBI and Grove City Police. Prosecutors say Hartman took pictures of a girl under the age of 18 as she was being sexually exploit...

    More >>

     A New Castle man could be sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty in federal court to a charge of sex trafficking of a child. Ronald Kyle Hartman, 28, entered the plea on Monday in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh. Hartman, along with 24-year-old David Monrean, also of New Castle, were indicted in January following an investigation by the FBI and Grove City Police. Prosecutors say Hartman took pictures of a girl under the age of 18 as she was being sexually exploit...

    More >>
  • Glasses available on first come, first served basis

    Valley events offering free eclipse viewing glasses

    Valley events offering free eclipse viewing glasses

    Saturday, August 19 2017 2:01 PM EDT2017-08-19 18:01:12 GMT

    If you're one of the people who scrambled for those special viewing glasses and couldn't find a pair for Monday's partial eclipse, there are several places in the Valley holding free viewing events where the glasses will also be provided free of charge. 

    More >>

    If you're one of the people who scrambled for those special viewing glasses and couldn't find a pair for Monday's partial eclipse, there are several places in the Valley holding free viewing events where the glasses will also be provided free of charge. 

    More >>
  • SpotlightSpotlightMore>>

  • Stuff the Bus!

    Stuff the Bus!

    Sunday, August 13 2017 7:52 PM EDT2017-08-13 23:52:49 GMT

    21 WFMJ, Great Clips, Cocca’s Pizza and Huntington Bank have teamed up with the United Way to “Stuff the Bus,” now through September 3rd.   

    More >>

    21 WFMJ, Great Clips, Cocca’s Pizza and Huntington Bank have teamed up with the United Way to “Stuff the Bus,” now through September 3rd.   

    More >>
  • Panerathon 2017 Team Peacock Registration

    Panerathon 2017 Team Peacock Registration

    Sunday, July 30 2017 8:13 PM EDT2017-07-31 00:13:49 GMT

    Join 21 WFMJ this year for Panerathon 2017!  We want to have the biggest team at Panerathon this year and we need your help. 

    More >>

    Join 21 WFMJ this year for Panerathon 2017!  We want to have the biggest team at Panerathon this year and we need your help. 

    More >>
  • Weather Pics

    Weather Pics

    Check out weather related pics from our viewers!  Please send your pics to weatherpics@wfmj.com.

    More >>

    Check out weather related pics from our viewers!  Please send your pics to weatherpics@wfmj.com.

    More >>
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Police nab two men after Warren market robbery

    Police nab two men after Warren market robbery

    Saturday, August 19 2017 8:03 AM EDT2017-08-19 12:03:51 GMT

    Two men are in the Trumbull County Jail after Warren Police tracked down two suspects wanted for an early morning robbery.

    More >>

    Two men are in the Trumbull County Jail after Warren Police tracked down two suspects wanted for an early morning robbery.

    More >>
  • New Castle man convicted of child sex trafficking

    New Castle man convicted of child sex trafficking

    Saturday, August 19 2017 2:46 PM EDT2017-08-19 18:46:42 GMT

     A New Castle man could be sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty in federal court to a charge of sex trafficking of a child. Ronald Kyle Hartman, 28, entered the plea on Monday in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh. Hartman, along with 24-year-old David Monrean, also of New Castle, were indicted in January following an investigation by the FBI and Grove City Police. Prosecutors say Hartman took pictures of a girl under the age of 18 as she was being sexually exploit...

    More >>

     A New Castle man could be sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty in federal court to a charge of sex trafficking of a child. Ronald Kyle Hartman, 28, entered the plea on Monday in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh. Hartman, along with 24-year-old David Monrean, also of New Castle, were indicted in January following an investigation by the FBI and Grove City Police. Prosecutors say Hartman took pictures of a girl under the age of 18 as she was being sexually exploit...

    More >>
  • Sheriff calls Warren man 'kingpin' of meth

    Sheriff calls Warren man 'kingpin' of meth

    Friday, August 18 2017 3:49 PM EDT2017-08-18 19:49:54 GMT
    Evidence gathered during Kacenski's arrestEvidence gathered during Kacenski's arrest

    Authorities in West Virginia have arrested a man that the local sheriff is calling one of the “kingpins of meth.” Adam Gissy, Sheriff of Lewis County West Virginia said that Steven Kacenski, 46, of Warren is charged with delivery of a controlled substance. 

    More >>

    Authorities in West Virginia have arrested a man that the local sheriff is calling one of the “kingpins of meth.” Adam Gissy, Sheriff of Lewis County West Virginia said that Steven Kacenski, 46, of Warren is charged with delivery of a controlled substance. 

    More >>
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms