Mill Creek park director named in $2.2 million 'retaliation' law - WFMJ.com News weather sports for Youngstown-Warren Ohio

Mill Creek park director named in $2.2 million 'retaliation' lawsuit

Posted: Updated:
Aaron Young Aaron Young

Controversial changes and decisions at Mill Creek MetroParks have turned into a $2.2 million dollar lawsuit against the park board, its executive director, members of the park police department and the operator of the park cafe.

Patricia Tinkler and Peter Mitchell Lynch, who formerly operated Friends Roastery in Salem and the Garden Cafe in the park, filed a civil rights lawsuit in U.S. District Court.

The suit claims that Tinkler and Lynch were victims of alleged retaliation by Aaron Young, after they became critical of some of his actions when he became the park's Executive Director.

The couple claims they operated the Garden Cafe at Fellows Riverside Garden without any issues since 2015, until August 2016, when the park board terminated their lease nearly a year and a half before it was to expire.

The suit alleges that a few months prior to losing their lease, there were “dramatic upheavals” in MetroParks management which undermined the couple’s relationship with park management.

The lawsuit cites several examples of controversial moves by the park board at the time, including the termination of several long time employees, a debate over the board's position on fracking and injection wells, as well as a decision to euthanize 238 geese that park officials say had become a nuisance.

Tinkler and Lynch say they participated in the public debate, much of which focused on criticism of Young and his decisions.

Lynch claims that Young told him in August that their cafe lease had been terminated because they had “three strikes” against them.

The lawsuit alleges that Young stated that the first two of those “strikes: were that Lynch had “liked” a Facebook post criticizing Young, and that Tinkler had told another person that Young’s conduct and all the controversy it creates were hurting business and costing Friends revenue.

The third alleged “strike” was that Lynch had told an adult park intern that he had heard rumors about an alleged affair she was having with an park employee.

Lynch claims that as a result, Young had members of the park police department investigate him and Tinkler in order to harass and intimidate them.

The lawsuit says that that Young later informed the couple that the lease was actually terminated for their failure to pay the rent. Lynch and Tinkler deny that they were behind on rent payments, according to the suit.

The suit also names Jack Kravitz and Kravitz Delicatessen as defendants, claiming Kravitz negotiated his subsequent contract to operate the Garden Cafe while Lynch and Tinkler still had a valid contract.

In addition to alleging a breach of contract, the couple says the actions of the defendants violated their rights to free speech and to assemble.

The suit asks for a jury trial, seeking a total of $2.2 million in damages for “financial, mental and emotional injury and mental and physical anguish and suffering, humiliation and embarrassment.”

None of the defendants have filed a response to the lawsuit, which was just filed on Thursday.

21 News has reached out to officials from the park and Jack Kravitz, who have yet to issue a reaction.

The lawsuit can be viewed here

  • More From wfmj.comHot ClicksMore>>

  • Mother of girl declared dead twice slams doctors at funeral

    Mother of girl declared dead twice slams doctors at funeral

    Wednesday, July 11 2018 3:52 PM EDT2018-07-11 19:52:14 GMT
    (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File). FILE - In this Dec. 23, 2015, file photo, a photo of Jahi McMath is shown on a video screen next to her uncle Timothy Whisenton at a news conference in San Francisco. The mother of a girl at the center of a medical and relig...(AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File). FILE - In this Dec. 23, 2015, file photo, a photo of Jahi McMath is shown on a video screen next to her uncle Timothy Whisenton at a news conference in San Francisco. The mother of a girl at the center of a medical and relig...
    Dozens of family members, friends and other mourners have filed into a Northern California church for the funeral of a teenage girl at the center of a medical and religious debate over brain death.More >>
    Dozens of family members, friends and other mourners have filed into a Northern California church for the funeral of a teenage girl at the center of a medical and religious debate over brain death.More >>
  • Study provides clues to fate of early North American dogs

    Study provides clues to fate of early North American dogs

    Monday, July 9 2018 8:28 PM EDT2018-07-10 00:28:18 GMT
    (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer, File). FILE - In this Feb. 15, 2016, file photo, a xoloitzcuintli is shown in the ring during the non-sporting group competition at the140th Westminster Kennel Club dog show, at Madison Square Garden in New York. A new study pu...(AP Photo/Mary Altaffer, File). FILE - In this Feb. 15, 2016, file photo, a xoloitzcuintli is shown in the ring during the non-sporting group competition at the140th Westminster Kennel Club dog show, at Madison Square Garden in New York. A new study pu...
    New study provides clues to fate of early North American dogs that were all but wiped out after the arrival of Europeans.More >>
    New study provides clues to fate of early North American dogs that were all but wiped out after the arrival of Europeans.More >>
  • Buddhist meditation may calm team trapped in Thai cave

    Buddhist meditation may calm team trapped in Thai cave

    Monday, July 9 2018 6:36 PM EDT2018-07-09 22:36:34 GMT
    (Tham Luang Rescue Operation Center via AP, File). FILE - In this handout photo released by Tham Luang Rescue Operation Center, Thai rescue teams use headlamps to enter a pitch-black cave complex where 12 boys and their soccer coach went missing, in Ma...(Tham Luang Rescue Operation Center via AP, File). FILE - In this handout photo released by Tham Luang Rescue Operation Center, Thai rescue teams use headlamps to enter a pitch-black cave complex where 12 boys and their soccer coach went missing, in Ma...
    The soccer coach stranded with 12 boys in a flooded Thai cave spent a decade as a Buddhist monk, honing a meditation skill that may serve him well during their ordeal.More >>
    The soccer coach stranded with 12 boys in a flooded Thai cave spent a decade as a Buddhist monk, honing a meditation skill that may serve him well during their ordeal.More >>
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms