High court rules on $2.4 million award to former Valley insuranc - WFMJ.com News weather sports for Youngstown-Warren Ohio

High court rules on $2.4 million award to former Valley insurance agent

Posted: Updated:
Christine Lucarell Oliver Christine Lucarell Oliver
COLUMBUS, Ohio -

The attorney for Canfield City Council member Christine Lucarell Oliver says he his reviewing an Ohio Supreme Court decision on the nearly $2.4 million dollars she was awarded in a lawsuit against an insurance company.

The high court ruled on Thursday that Lucarell Oliver was not entitled to punitive damages in her breach-of-contract claim against Nationwide Insurance.

Five years ago a jury in Mahoning County recommended that Lucarell Oliver was entitled to nearly $43 million from Nationwide, who Luccarell Oliver had sued claiming that the company had convinced her to open a new insurance agency when it intended to fire her after she generated a profitable business.

The jury award was reduced by the trial judge and further reduced on appeal to $2,075,678 in compensatory damages and $200,020 in punitive damages.

Asked what the Supreme Court's decision means to damages awarded to Lucarell Oliver, her attorney, Randy J. Hart of Cleveland told 21 News that he is reviewing the 21-page ruling.

Meanwhile Eric Hardgrove, the Director of Corporate COmmunications for Nationwide issued a statement Thursday saying:

Nationwide is pleased with the court's decision, which vindicates Nationwide. The decision soundly rejects the charge that Nationwide engaged in fraud.  As we have maintained throughout this case, our objective is and has always been to help position our agents for success, not failure.   

This important decision by the Ohio Supreme Court supports that Nationwide acted in good faith in seeking to enforce the terms of its contracts and further favorably clarifies the law surrounding contractual relations in Ohio for both Nationwide and the business community. 

This decision corrects fundamental legal errors that were made by the lower courts that led to an improper jury verdict, while affirming what numerous courts have previously found, that Nationwide's exclusive agents are independent contractors, not employees. 

The case has been sent back to the Seventh District Court of Appeals for further consideration

The Ohio Supreme Court's decision may be seen here

  • More From wfmj.comHot ClicksMore>>

  • In posthumous message, Hawking says science under threat

    In posthumous message, Hawking says science under threat

    Wednesday, October 17 2018 8:19 PM EDT2018-10-18 00:19:58 GMT
    Stephen Hawking has spoken from beyond the grave to warn that science and education are under threat around the world.More >>
    Stephen Hawking has spoken from beyond the grave to warn that science and education are under threat around the world.More >>
  • Salesforce vs. Twitter in San Francisco homeless tax fight

    Salesforce vs. Twitter in San Francisco homeless tax fight

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 10:54 PM EDT2018-10-17 02:54:04 GMT
    (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu). In this Oct. 1, 2018 photo, Stormy Nichole Day, left, sits on a sidewalk on Haight Street with Nord (last name not given) and his dog Hobo while interviewed about being homeless in San Francisco. A measure on San Francisco's Nov. ...(AP Photo/Jeff Chiu). In this Oct. 1, 2018 photo, Stormy Nichole Day, left, sits on a sidewalk on Haight Street with Nord (last name not given) and his dog Hobo while interviewed about being homeless in San Francisco. A measure on San Francisco's Nov. ...
    San Francisco voters have a measure on the Nov. 6 ballot that would tax hundreds of the city's wealthiest companies to help thousands of homeless and mentally ill.More >>
    San Francisco voters have a measure on the Nov. 6 ballot that would tax hundreds of the city's wealthiest companies to help thousands of homeless and mentally ill.More >>
  • Trump marvels at hurricane damage, hears stories of struggle

    Trump marvels at hurricane damage, hears stories of struggle

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 12:59 PM EDT2018-10-16 16:59:45 GMT
    (AP Photo/Evan Vucci). President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump board Air Force One for a trip to visit areas affected by Hurricane Michael, Monday, Oct. 15, 2018, in Andrews Air Force Base, Md.(AP Photo/Evan Vucci). President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump board Air Force One for a trip to visit areas affected by Hurricane Michael, Monday, Oct. 15, 2018, in Andrews Air Force Base, Md.
    Trump, first lady arrive in Florida to survey areas devastated by Hurricane Michael.More >>
    Trump, first lady arrive in Florida to survey areas devastated by Hurricane Michael.More >>
  • More NewsMore>>

  • Austintown woman facing fine after TSA finds loaded handgun

    Austintown woman facing fine after TSA finds loaded handgun

    Friday, October 19 2018 5:50 PM EDT2018-10-19 21:50:24 GMT

    An Austintown woman could be required to pay nearly $4,000 after she was allegedly found with a loaded gun at the Pittsburgh airport.  

    More >>

    An Austintown woman could be required to pay nearly $4,000 after she was allegedly found with a loaded gun at the Pittsburgh airport.  

    More >>
  • Ohio U.S. Senate Candidate fires serious misconduct allegations against incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown

    Ohio U.S. Senate Candidate fires serious misconduct allegations against incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown

    Friday, October 19 2018 5:39 PM EDT2018-10-19 21:39:07 GMT
    Republican U.S. Senate Candidate, Jim Renacci is firing serious misconduct allegations against incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown.    Brown is now threatening to sue Renacci over the accusations.   On Wednesday Rennacci told a Cincinnati newspaper multiple women contacted him with allegations they were abused by Senator Brown.   On Thursday he admitted to a West Virginia radio show the allegations were unsubstantiated.   Renacci then came forward with a stat...More >>
    Republican U.S. Senate Candidate, Jim Renacci is firing serious misconduct allegations against incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown.    Brown is now threatening to sue Renacci over the accusations.   On Wednesday Rennacci told a Cincinnati newspaper multiple women contacted him with allegations they were abused by Senator Brown.   On Thursday he admitted to a West Virginia radio show the allegations were unsubstantiated.   Renacci then came forward with a stat...More >>
  • UPDATE

    Third suspect charged with homicide, conspiracy in New Castle triple homicide

    Third suspect charged with homicide, conspiracy in New Castle triple homicide

    Friday, October 19 2018 4:21 PM EDT2018-10-19 20:21:51 GMT

    Charges have officially been filed against Anthony "Mook" Cooper in connection with a triple homicide in New Castle.

    More >>

    Charges have officially been filed against Anthony "Mook" Cooper in connection with a triple homicide in New Castle.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms