California judge rules that coffee requires cancer warning - WFMJ.com News weather sports for Youngstown-Warren Ohio

California judge rules that coffee requires cancer warning

Posted: Updated:

By BRIAN MELLEY
Associated Press

LOS ANGELES (AP) - Scientists haven't rendered a verdict on whether coffee is good or bad for you but a California judge has. He says coffee sellers in the state should have to post cancer warnings.

The culprit is a chemical produced in the bean roasting process that is a known carcinogen and has been at the heart of an eight-year legal struggle between a tiny nonprofit group and Big Coffee.

The Council for Education and Research on Toxics wanted the coffee industry to remove acrylamide from its processing - like potato chip makers did when it sued them years ago - or disclose the danger in ominous warning signs or labels. The industry, led by Starbucks Corp., said the level of the chemical in coffee isn't harmful and any risks are outweighed by benefits.

Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Elihu Berle said Wednesday that the coffee makers hadn't presented the proper grounds at trial to prevail.

"While plaintiff offered evidence that consumption of coffee increases the risk of harm to the fetus, to infants, to children and to adults, defendants' medical and epidemiology experts testified that they had no opinion on causation," Berle wrote in his proposed ruling. "Defendants failed to satisfy their burden of proving ... that consumption of coffee confers a benefit to human health."

The suit was brought against Starbucks and 90 companies under a controversial law passed by California voters in 1986 that has been credited with culling cancer-causing chemicals from myriad products and also criticized for leading to quick settlement shakedowns.

The Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, better known as Proposition 65, requires warning labels for about 900 chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects. It allows private citizens, advocacy groups and attorneys to sue on behalf of the state and collect a portion of civil penalties for failure to provide warnings.

"This lawsuit has made a mockery of Prop. 65, has confused consumers, and does nothing to improve public health," said William Murray, president and CEO of the National Coffee Association, who added that coffee had been shown to be a healthy beverage.

Scientific evidence on coffee has gone back and forth for a long time, but concerns have eased recently about possible dangers of coffee, with some studies finding health benefits.

In 2016, the cancer agency of the World Health Organization moved coffee off its "possible carcinogen" list.

Studies indicate coffee is unlikely to cause breast, prostate or pancreatic cancer, and it seems to lower the risks for liver and uterine cancers, the agency said. Evidence is inadequate to determine its effect on dozens of other cancer types.

Coffee companies have said it's not feasible to remove acrylamide from their product without ruining the flavor.

But attorney Raphael Metzger, who brought the lawsuit and drinks a few cups of coffee a day, said the industry could remove the chemical without impairing taste.

"I firmly believe if the potato chip industry can do it, so can the coffee industry," Metzger said. "A warning won't be that effective because it's an addictive product."

Many coffee shops have already posted warnings that say acrylamide is cancer-causing chemical found in coffee. But signs that are supposed to be posted at the point of sale are often found in places not easily visible, such as below the counter where cream and sugar are available.

Customers at shops that post warnings are often unaware or unconcerned about them.

Afternoon coffee drinkers at a Los Angeles Starbucks said they might look into the warning or give coffee drinking a second thought after the ruling, but the cup of joe was likely to win out.

"I just don't think it would stop me," said Jen Bitterman, a digital marketing technologist. "I love the taste, I love the ritual, I love the high, the energy, and I think I'm addicted to it."

Darlington Ibekwe, a lawyer in Los Angeles, said a cancer warning would be annoying but wouldn't stop him from treating himself to three lattes a week.

"It's like cigarettes. Like, damn, now I've got to see this?" he said. "Dude, I'm enjoying my coffee."

The defendants have a couple weeks to challenge the ruling before it is final and could seek relief from an appellate court.

If the ruling stands, it could come with a stiff financial penalty and could rattle consumers beyond state lines.

The judge can set another phase of trial to consider potential civil penalties up to $2,500 per person exposed each day over eight years. That could be an astronomical sum in a state with close to 40 million residents, though such a massive fine is unlikely.

California's outsized market could make it difficult to tailor packaging with warning labels specifically to stores in the state.

That means out-of-state coffee drinkers could also take their coffee with a cancer warning. Cream and sugar would still be optional.

___

Associated Press writer Amanda Lee Myers in Los Angeles and AP Chief Medical Writer Marilynn Marchione in Milwaukee contributed to this story.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Hot ClicksHot ClicksMore>>

  • Mexico's crackdown forces migrants to more dangerous routes

    Mexico's crackdown forces migrants to more dangerous routes

    Friday, April 26 2019 3:23 AM EDT2019-04-26 07:23:05 GMT
    (AP Photo/Moises Castillo). Honduran migrants Sandra Montoya, her husband Jose Vallecillo and their daughter Brittany rest on the railroad track before a freight train leaves Arriaga, Chiapas state, Mexico, Wednesday, April 24, 2019. The train known as...(AP Photo/Moises Castillo). Honduran migrants Sandra Montoya, her husband Jose Vallecillo and their daughter Brittany rest on the railroad track before a freight train leaves Arriaga, Chiapas state, Mexico, Wednesday, April 24, 2019. The train known as...
    (AP Photo/Moises Castillo). Honduran migrants Sandra Montoya, her husband Jose Vallecillo and their daughter Brittany rest on the railroad track before a freight train leaves Arriaga, Chiapas state, Mexico, Wednesday, April 24, 2019. The train known as...(AP Photo/Moises Castillo). Honduran migrants Sandra Montoya, her husband Jose Vallecillo and their daughter Brittany rest on the railroad track before a freight train leaves Arriaga, Chiapas state, Mexico, Wednesday, April 24, 2019. The train known as...
    Mexico's crackdown on migration is not cutting off the flow of Central Americans, but rather forcing migrants into the shadows and greater danger, despite government assurances that the central thrust of its policy...More >>
    Mexico's crackdown on migration is not cutting off the flow of Central Americans, but rather forcing migrants into the shadows and greater danger, despite government assurances that the central thrust of its policy is to protect them.More >>
  • Iraq veteran jailed after car plows into pedestrians; 8 hurt

    Iraq veteran jailed after car plows into pedestrians; 8 hurt

    Friday, April 26 2019 1:23 AM EDT2019-04-26 05:23:04 GMT
    (AP Photo/Cody Glenn). Police and road crews work the scene after a car crash at the intersection of El Camino Real and Sunnyvale Road in Sunnyvale, Calif., on Wednesday, April 24, 2019. Investigators are working to determine the cause of the crash in ...(AP Photo/Cody Glenn). Police and road crews work the scene after a car crash at the intersection of El Camino Real and Sunnyvale Road in Sunnyvale, Calif., on Wednesday, April 24, 2019. Investigators are working to determine the cause of the crash in ...
    (AP Photo/Cody Glenn). Police and road crews work the scene after a car crash at the intersection of El Camino Real and Sunnyvale Road in Sunnyvale, Calif., on Wednesday, April 24, 2019. Investigators are working to determine the cause of the crash in ...(AP Photo/Cody Glenn). Police and road crews work the scene after a car crash at the intersection of El Camino Real and Sunnyvale Road in Sunnyvale, Calif., on Wednesday, April 24, 2019. Investigators are working to determine the cause of the crash in ...
    Police say a California motorist told investigators that he deliberately drove into a crosswalk in a quiet Silicon Valley suburb, hitting seven people and injuring eight, but did not say why.More >>
    Police say a California motorist told investigators that he deliberately drove into a crosswalk in a quiet Silicon Valley suburb, hitting seven people and injuring eight, but did not say why.More >>
  • Giraffes a tentative step closer toward federal protections

    Giraffes a tentative step closer toward federal protections

    Friday, April 26 2019 1:01 AM EDT2019-04-26 05:01:42 GMT
    (AP Photo/Ben Curtis, File). FILE - In this Tuesday, March 20, 2018 file photo, giraffes and zebras congregate under the shade of a tree in the afternoon in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania. The Trump administration has taken a first step toward extendin...(AP Photo/Ben Curtis, File). FILE - In this Tuesday, March 20, 2018 file photo, giraffes and zebras congregate under the shade of a tree in the afternoon in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania. The Trump administration has taken a first step toward extendin...
    (AP Photo/Ben Curtis, File). FILE - In this Tuesday, March 20, 2018 file photo, giraffes and zebras congregate under the shade of a tree in the afternoon in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania. The Trump administration has taken a first step toward extendin...(AP Photo/Ben Curtis, File). FILE - In this Tuesday, March 20, 2018 file photo, giraffes and zebras congregate under the shade of a tree in the afternoon in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania. The Trump administration has taken a first step toward extendin...
    The Trump administration has taken a first step toward extending protections for giraffes under the Endangered Species Act.More >>
    The Trump administration has taken a first step toward extending protections for giraffes under the Endangered Species Act.More >>
  • More NewsMore>>

  • Biden enters Democratic race with strong anti-Trump theme

    Biden enters Democratic race with strong anti-Trump theme

    Friday, April 26 2019 3:22 AM EDT2019-04-26 07:22:31 GMT
    (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File). FILE - In this March 26, 2019, file photo, former Vice President Joe Biden speaks at the Biden Courage Awards in New York.(AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File). FILE - In this March 26, 2019, file photo, former Vice President Joe Biden speaks at the Biden Courage Awards in New York.
    (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File). FILE - In this March 26, 2019, file photo, former Vice President Joe Biden speaks at the Biden Courage Awards in New York.(AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File). FILE - In this March 26, 2019, file photo, former Vice President Joe Biden speaks at the Biden Courage Awards in New York.
    Former Vice President Joe Biden launches 2020 presidential campaign.More >>
    Former Vice President Joe Biden launches 2020 presidential campaign.More >>
  • Anthony Traficanti honored in Austintown

    Anthony Traficanti honored in Austintown

    Thursday, April 25 2019 11:35 PM EDT2019-04-26 03:35:36 GMT
    Mahoning County Commissioner Anthony Traficanti was he was honored in Austintown Thursday night.  Traficanti was given the "Citizen of the Year" award from the United Veterans Council. His fellow commissioners Carol Rimedio-Righetti and Dave Ditzler spoke on his behalf at the event.  Traficanti has been a Mahoning County Commissioner since 2005 and is a part of several Valley organizations and committees.More >>
    Mahoning County Commissioner Anthony Traficanti was he was honored in Austintown Thursday night.  Traficanti was given the "Citizen of the Year" award from the United Veterans Council. His fellow commissioners Carol Rimedio-Righetti and Dave Ditzler spoke on his behalf at the event.  Traficanti has been a Mahoning County Commissioner since 2005 and is a part of several Valley organizations and committees.More >>
  • Educators honored in Mercer County

    Educators honored in Mercer County

    Thursday, April 25 2019 11:08 PM EDT2019-04-26 03:08:34 GMT
    There were 15 educators from Mercer and Lawrence County school districts awarded for their leadership and commitment Thursday night. The awards were handed out to educators who the event's organizers say show up to work tirelessly every day to teach children across the Shenango Valley. The event was hosted by the Shenango Valley & Lawrence County Chambers of Commerce in partnership with Laurel Technical Institute.  "We hold this to support our educators...More >>
    There were 15 educators from Mercer and Lawrence County school districts awarded for their leadership and commitment Thursday night. The awards were handed out to educators who the event's organizers say show up to work tirelessly every day to teach children across the Shenango Valley. The event was hosted by the Shenango Valley & Lawrence County Chambers of Commerce in partnership with Laurel Technical Institute.  "We hold this to support our educators...More >>
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms