Former Howland woman sent back to death row - WFMJ.com News weather sports for Youngstown-Warren Ohio

Former Howland woman sent back to death row

Posted: Updated:
WARREN, Ohio - A former Howland woman will remain the only woman sitting on Death Row in Ohio.

Donna Roberts has once again been sentenced to death for conspiring with her lover to murder her husband Robert Fingerhut in 2001.

In October, the Ohio Supreme Court agreed with a defense attorney who argued that the judge who sentenced Roberts earlier had ignored evidence in the case. The justices upheld her guilty verdict, but sent the case back to Trumbull County court for re-sentencing.

Presiding over a hearing for Roberts on Wednesday, Trumbull County Common Pleas Court Judge Ronald Rice denied her motion to hold a full penalty phase hearing and again sentenced her to death.

It wasn't the first time the high court vacated Roberts's 2003 death sentence. In 2006 the justices sent her case back to Trumbull County Court. But after hearing statements from Roberts in the remanded case, the trial court re-sentenced her to death.

In 2001, police-monitored phone calls and letter exchanges between Roberts and her lover, prison inmate Nathaniel Jackson, showed they planned to murder Fingerhut.

Two days after Jackson's release from prison in December 2001, Fingerhut was shot to death at home. Jackson was convicted of murdering Fingerhut and was sentenced to death.

In late March of this year, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear the appeal made by 69-year-old Roberts and co-conspirator Jackson.

Judge Rice has ordered that Roberts be sent to the Ohio Reformatory for Women where she will be held until her execution.

Until Wednesday, there were 139 people on death row.  However, Governor John Kasich announced commuted the death sentence of Arthur Tyler to life in prison without the possibility of parole. 

Tyler was convicted in Cuyahoga County in 1986 for the murder of 74-year-old Sander Leach. 

Kasich issued the following statement:

“After carefully reviewing the case record with my legal counsel and studying the recommendations of the Parole Board, I’ve decided to commute Arthur Tyler’s sentence to life in prison without the possibility of parole.  The questions that continue around this case are fundamental and the irregularities in the court proceedings are troubling. 

Arthur Tyler’s crime against Sander Leach and his family was heinous and this commutation in no way diminishes that and I pray that Mr. Leach’s family can find peace and healing.”

  • More NewsMore>>

  • US college teams in Barcelona during van attack, players OK

    US college teams in Barcelona during van attack, players OK

    Thursday, August 17 2017 7:12 PM EDT2017-08-17 23:12:22 GMT
    Oregon State and Clemson men's basketball teams were at a hotel in Barcelona near where a van drove into pedestrians.More >>
    Oregon State and Clemson men's basketball teams were at a hotel in Barcelona near where a van drove into pedestrians.More >>
  • West Nile virus found in Mahoning and Columbiana counties

    West Nile virus found in Mahoning and Columbiana counties

    Thursday, August 17 2017 7:02 PM EDT2017-08-17 23:02:14 GMT

    Local health departments want residents to know that mosquitoes carrying the West Nile virus have been discovered in Mahoning and Columbiana counties. 

    More >>

    Local health departments want residents to know that mosquitoes carrying the West Nile virus have been discovered in Mahoning and Columbiana counties. 

    More >>
  • Under fire _ from GOP _ Trump digs in on Confederate icons

    Under fire _ from GOP _ Trump digs in on Confederate icons

    Thursday, August 17 2017 7:00 PM EDT2017-08-17 23:00:41 GMT
    President Donald Trump has abruptly dismantled two of his White House business councils-an apparent attempt to manage his increasing isolation and the continued fallout from his combative comments on racially...More >>
    President Donald Trump has abruptly dismantled two of his White House business councils-an apparent attempt to manage his increasing isolation and the continued fallout from his combative comments on racially charged violence in Charlottesville, Virginia.More >>
  • SpotlightSpotlightMore>>

  • Stuff the Bus!

    Stuff the Bus!

    Sunday, August 13 2017 7:52 PM EDT2017-08-13 23:52:49 GMT

    21 WFMJ, Great Clips, Cocca’s Pizza and Huntington Bank have teamed up with the United Way to “Stuff the Bus,” now through September 3rd.   

    More >>

    21 WFMJ, Great Clips, Cocca’s Pizza and Huntington Bank have teamed up with the United Way to “Stuff the Bus,” now through September 3rd.   

    More >>
  • Panerathon 2017 Team Peacock Registration

    Panerathon 2017 Team Peacock Registration

    Sunday, July 30 2017 8:13 PM EDT2017-07-31 00:13:49 GMT

    Join 21 WFMJ this year for Panerathon 2017!  We want to have the biggest team at Panerathon this year and we need your help. 

    More >>

    Join 21 WFMJ this year for Panerathon 2017!  We want to have the biggest team at Panerathon this year and we need your help. 

    More >>
  • Weather Pics

    Weather Pics

    Check out weather related pics from our viewers!  Please send your pics to weatherpics@wfmj.com.

    More >>

    Check out weather related pics from our viewers!  Please send your pics to weatherpics@wfmj.com.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms