Unique dental feature helped identify missing body - 21 News Now, More Local News for Youngstown, Ohio -

Unique dental feature helped identify missing body

Posted: Updated:

YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio - A national missing persons database, as well as a unique dental feature, ultimately solved the disappearance of business owner James Donofrio.

The 64-year-old owner of the Avalon Gardens bar and restaurant has been missing since September 2011, when his abandoned Landrover was found near the Mahoning River under the Market Street bridge.

Detectives searched extensively in and around the river, however, they just learned that Donofrio's remains were found more than one year ago on March 25th, 2012.

The remains were found on the shoreline of the Ohio River near the West Virginia-Ohio border.

West Virginia State Patrol has jurisdiction over the waterway and was handling the case of an unidentified man.

Donofrio's sister-in-law, Nancy Donofrio, and his daughter Carli tell 21 News they were shocked to learn their loved one's body has been lying unidentified in a West Virginia morgue for this long.

"We're on all the national databases. Jim's DNA, and his dental records and what not, have been (on the databases) for over a year now. So certainly the information was there," Nancy Donofrio says. "So yes, we are very unclear as to why it took this amount of time."

Just two weeks ago, West Virginia authorities entered information into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System known as "NamUs."

By Monday, April 8th there was a match, according to Director of Communications for NamUs, Todd Matthews.

"It was one of our own staffers, Richard Scanlon who saw a unique dental feature, related to a root canal, and looked into it further," Matthews says. "Each state has it's own system that doesn't always connect with each other. So NamUs is the connection. It's the bridge between the states."

Matthews says that this case was a pure "dental hit," and they found the information fairly quickly without any DNA. 

Authorities with NamUs plan to talk to Donofrio's family as soon as possible and explain to them in detail how his identification was made.

They say it's possible that West Virginia officials tried their state database, and another national database first, before submitting information to NamUs.

Donofrio's information has been on the missing persons website for more than a year, submitted initially by Donofrio's daughter Carli, as well as Youngstown police detectives.

An autopsy report could be completed by the end of the week.

Sources say the autopsy was actually performed on Donofrio the day his body was found, and homicide has been ruled out because there were no signs of foul play.

  • More NewsMore>>

  • East Palestine football players raise awareness about ALS

    East Palestine football players raise awareness about ALS

    One local high school football team took the ALS ice bucket challenge to new heights Thursday night.More >>
    One local high school football team took the ALS ice bucket challenge to new heights Thursday night.More >>
  • A helping hand for local veterans

    A helping hand for local veterans

    Saturday, August 23 2014 12:02 PM EDT2014-08-23 16:02:15 GMT
    VIENNA, Ohio- Members of the community are raising money to help meet the needs of wounded soldiers and disabled veterans locally. The first annual Freedom Warrior Golf Outing drew hundreds of people together for the cause Friday.More >>
    VIENNA, Ohio- Members of the community are raising money to help meet the needs of wounded soldiers and disabled veterans locally. The first annual Freedom Warrior Golf Outing drew hundreds of people together for the cause Friday.More >>
  • Youngstown residents gather to stop cycle of violence

    Youngstown residents gather to stop cycle of violence

    Saturday, August 23 2014 11:30 AM EDT2014-08-23 15:30:05 GMT
    Youngstown's latest homicide, the shooting death of 17 year old Shawn Cortez, has residents gathering to take back their city from violence.On Friday members of the Food 4 Your Soul ministries offered up prayers for peace while serving up food. They are reaching out to young people, in an effort to stop the cycle of violence in Youngstown."I don't want our children to be fearful when they go to school. They just need to know that there's good resources.. There's good people who are hear for t...More >>
    Youngstown's latest homicide, the shooting death of 17 year old Shawn Cortez, has residents gathering to take back their city from violence.On Friday members of the Food 4 Your Soul ministries offered up prayers for peace while serving up food. They are reaching out to young people, in an effort to stop the cycle of violence in Youngstown."I don't want our children to be fearful when they go to school. They just need to know that there's good resources.. There's good people who are hear for t...More >>
  • More From wfmj.comMore>>

  • Police: Couple used dog to lure 2 Amish girls

    Police: Couple used dog to lure 2 Amish girls

    Thursday, August 21 2014 10:04 PM EDT2014-08-22 02:04:19 GMT
    A woman accused along with her boyfriend of abducting and sexually abusing two young Amish sisters is due in court for a preliminary hearing.More >>
    A northern New York couple used a dog to lure two Amish sisters from their family farm stand with a plan to turn them into slaves, an investigator said Thursday.More >>
  • State won't sell naming rights for Ohio Turnpike

    State won't sell naming rights for Ohio Turnpike

    Thursday, August 21 2014 9:30 PM EDT2014-08-22 01:30:13 GMT
    Ohio will pursue opportunities to collect revenue through sponsorships along the state turnpike but will not sell naming rights for the 241-mile toll road.More >>
    Ohio will pursue opportunities to collect revenue through sponsorships along the state turnpike but will not sell naming rights for the 241-mile toll road.
    More >>
  • Ohio State president meets with band leaders

    Ohio State president meets with band leaders

    Thursday, August 21 2014 9:23 PM EDT2014-08-22 01:23:42 GMT
    Courtesy:  NBC NewsCourtesy: NBC News
    Student and staff leaders of the Ohio State marching band have met with the university's president to share concerns over the firing of a popular band directorMore >>
    Student and staff leaders of the Ohio State marching band have met with the university's president to share concerns over the firing of a popular band directorMore >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Worldnow and WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms