Mahoning Elections Board water leak raises concerns ahead of early voting

YOUNGSTOWN A water leak at the Mahoning County Board of Elections building sent water into the room housing vote-counting machines Monday morning, forcing staff to move equipment and delay testing scheduled for the day.
Board of Elections Chair David Betras said staff had to act quickly to protect scanners from damage. He argued the incident proves the Oak Hill Avenue facility is unfit for elections. “I’ve been warning the county commissioners this would happen,” Betras said. “It’s time the people demand they move the Board of Elections.”
Betras said contingency plans are in place, including access to backup equipment from other counties and vendors, but added the board should not have to rely on emergency measures to keep elections secure. He warned that if a leak happened closer to Election Day, it could be far more disruptive.
Commissioner Geno DiFabio said he went to the site after the leak and was assured no machines were damaged. He called the incident “unfortunate” but stressed the county’s response was quick. “We’re mitigating every issue we can down there, but sometimes things are going to happen, no matter where they are,” DiFabio said. He emphasized that backup machines are available and that “votes are sacred,” adding that commissioners remain committed to protecting the process.
The Oak Hill building has been a source of tension between the board and county commissioners. Earlier this month, the Board of Elections discussed whether to sue the commissioners to force action on relocating. While some board members argued progress was being made in talks, Betras said he has yet to see “substantial movement.”
The facility has faced repeated problems. Workers were evacuated earlier this year because of a smell, and staff spent weeks without air conditioning over the summer. The building also does not meet all Secretary of State compliance standards, though temporary fixes were allowed for the November election.
Commissioners have said they are exploring options for a new building but cautioned that finding and preparing a site large enough for elections is a process that will take time. DiFabio said Monday the specific leak came from an old pipe that has now been shut off.
Early voting in Mahoning County is scheduled to begin next week.
