Ohio Supreme Court upholds death sentence in Howland murder - WFMJ.com News weather sports for Youngstown-Warren Ohio

Ohio Supreme Court upholds death sentence in Howland murder

Posted: Updated:
Donna Roberts Donna Roberts
COLUMBUS, Ohio -

The Ohio Supreme Court upheld the death sentence of a Trumbull County man who is convicted of conspiring with a Howland woman to kill her ex-husband for insurance money.

44-year-old Nathaniel Jackson's death sentence is set to be carried out on July 15, 2020, according to a ruling handed down on Wednesday.

Jackson had been appealing a trial court's re-sentencing by arguing that the court did not properly consider his formal statement regarding his prison behavior.  

The court, in a majority opinion written by Justice Paul Pfeifer, said that although the trial court erred in consideration of Jackson's statement, the mistake was harmless as the statement did not carry much weight compared to his crimes.

In 2001, Robert Fingerhut had been residing with Donna Roberts, his ex-wife. Roberts exchanged letters and phone calls with Jackson, who was in prison at the time, plotting to kill Fingerhut when Jackson was released so she could collect more than $500,000 in life insurance proceeds.

Jackson was released from prison on December 9, 2001, and Fingerhut was found shot to death in Howland two days later.

Jackson was convicted in November 2002 of aggravated murder, aggravated burglary and aggravated robbery.  

Both he and Roberts were sentenced to death.  Roberts, 70, remains on death row awaiting an oral argument date in front of the Ohio Supreme Court.

The Trumbull man then began a decade-long appeals process that culminated in an August 2012 trial court re-sentencing.  

Jackson was again sentenced to death but soon after filed a Supreme Court appeal.  He did so on the grounds that trial court Judge John Stuard acted with bias, claiming that Stuard had been unfair during re-sentencing.

The Supreme Court said on Wednesday that Jackson's appeal failed to show that Judge Stuard displayed any "hostile feeling or spirit of ill will" toward him, one of his claims.   

The trial court did, according to Pfeifer, fail to discuss Jackson's allocution statement during their re-sentencing opinion.  

Jackson's statement discussed his educational certificates, service as a tutor, and good behavior in prison since his 2002 conviction.

The Supreme Court Justice said, however, that the statement added little to the evidence that was already before the court.  

"Evidence had established," according to Pfeifer, "that Jackson and Roberts planned Fingerhut’s death while Jackson was in prison earlier.  Under these circumstances, it is doubtful that Jackson’s claim about his adaptation to prison life could have carried much weight."

The Supreme Court therefore ruled that any omissions in the re-sentencing opinion were harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.

The court thus declined to send the case back for another new sentencing, instead, the error was rectified by an independent evaluation carried out by the Supreme Court.

In their evaluation, the court found that the Jackson's statement and other mitigating behavioral evidence held little significance in comparison to the months-long murder plot he and Roberts undertook.

The death penalty was therefore upheld by the Supreme Court.

Justices O'Connor, Kennedy, French, Klatt, and O'Donnell concurred with Pfeifer.  Justice Lanzinger was the court's lone dissent.

The full opinion can be read below:

  • More From wfmj.comHot ClicksMore>>

  • In posthumous message, Hawking says science under threat

    In posthumous message, Hawking says science under threat

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 4:59 PM EDT2018-10-16 20:59:54 GMT
    Stephen Hawking has spoken from beyond the grave to warn that science and education are under threat around the world.More >>
    Stephen Hawking has spoken from beyond the grave to warn that science and education are under threat around the world.More >>
  • Salesforce vs. Twitter in San Francisco homeless tax fight

    Salesforce vs. Twitter in San Francisco homeless tax fight

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 4:53 PM EDT2018-10-16 20:53:01 GMT
    (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu). In this Oct. 1, 2018 photo, Stormy Nichole Day, left, sits on a sidewalk on Haight Street with Nord (last name not given) and his dog Hobo while interviewed about being homeless in San Francisco. A measure on San Francisco's Nov. ...(AP Photo/Jeff Chiu). In this Oct. 1, 2018 photo, Stormy Nichole Day, left, sits on a sidewalk on Haight Street with Nord (last name not given) and his dog Hobo while interviewed about being homeless in San Francisco. A measure on San Francisco's Nov. ...
    San Francisco voters have a measure on the Nov. 6 ballot that would tax hundreds of the city's wealthiest companies to help thousands of homeless and mentally ill.More >>
    San Francisco voters have a measure on the Nov. 6 ballot that would tax hundreds of the city's wealthiest companies to help thousands of homeless and mentally ill.More >>
  • Trump marvels at hurricane damage, hears stories of struggle

    Trump marvels at hurricane damage, hears stories of struggle

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 12:59 PM EDT2018-10-16 16:59:45 GMT
    (AP Photo/Evan Vucci). President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump board Air Force One for a trip to visit areas affected by Hurricane Michael, Monday, Oct. 15, 2018, in Andrews Air Force Base, Md.(AP Photo/Evan Vucci). President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump board Air Force One for a trip to visit areas affected by Hurricane Michael, Monday, Oct. 15, 2018, in Andrews Air Force Base, Md.
    Trump, first lady arrive in Florida to survey areas devastated by Hurricane Michael.More >>
    Trump, first lady arrive in Florida to survey areas devastated by Hurricane Michael.More >>
  • More NewsMore>>

  • Tips for safe trick-or-treating & Halloween parties for kids with allergies

    Tips for safe trick-or-treating & Halloween parties for kids with allergies

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 5:17 PM EDT2018-10-16 21:17:45 GMT

    It's no secret that all of the neighborhood goblins and ghouls are looking forward to a scary good time this Halloween. But hidden dangers lurking inside the treats can play devilish tricks on kids with food allergies.  Depending on the severity of the allergies, even a trace amount of contagion could mean a serious reaction little haunters. But there are some tips that experts say can keep while they're trick or treating and at special events like classroom parties.  When...

    More >>

    It's no secret that all of the neighborhood goblins and ghouls are looking forward to a scary good time this Halloween. But hidden dangers lurking inside the treats can play devilish tricks on kids with food allergies.  Depending on the severity of the allergies, even a trace amount of contagion could mean a serious reaction little haunters. But there are some tips that experts say can keep while they're trick or treating and at special events like classroom parties.  When...

    More >>
  • Venture capital fund targets valley investments

    Venture capital fund targets valley investments

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 4:21 PM EDT2018-10-16 20:21:07 GMT
    A visit to the valley by a group of big city venture capitalists is starting to pay off.  The visit to Youngstown in February was part of the Comeback Cities Tour designed to show venture capitalists the opportunities for investments outside silicon valley and big cities. On Tuesday, Congressman Tim Ryan and the Youngstown Business Incubator announced the formation of a new  two point two million dollar venture capital fund to help start-up companies grow here in the Mahon...More >>
    A visit to the valley by a group of big city venture capitalists is starting to pay off.  The visit to Youngstown in February was part of the Comeback Cities Tour designed to show venture capitalists the opportunities for investments outside silicon valley and big cities. On Tuesday, Congressman Tim Ryan and the Youngstown Business Incubator announced the formation of a new  two point two million dollar venture capital fund to help start-up companies grow here in the Mahon...More >>
  • Police identify man, woman, child found dead in New Castle homicide

    Police identify man, woman, child found dead in New Castle homicide

    Tuesday, October 16 2018 4:02 PM EDT2018-10-16 20:02:39 GMT

    New Castle Police are at a home on what is being described as a triple homicide.

    More >>

    New Castle Police are at a home on what is being described as a triple homicide.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WFMJ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms